Missing a place? Let us Know

AJ Bombers 

1241 N Water Street Milwaukee, WI (414) 221-9999

Traditional American Hamburgers 
Barrie Burger, an outrageous chunky peanut butter bacon cheeseburger that

  • GOLD for AJ Bombers

Big Texan 

7701 E Interstate 40 Amarillo, TX (806) 342-5466

Steakhouse 
72-ounce Big Texan challenge which includes the 4.5 pound (2 kg) steak, a bread roll with butter, baked potato, ranch beans, shrimp cocktail

  • GOLD for Big Texan

Blakes BBQ and Burgers 

2916 Jeanetta St Houston, TX (713) 266-6860

Smoky burger on a butter soaked bun.


Brooklyn Ice Cream Factory 

97 Commercial St Brooklyn, NY (718) 349-2506

Michael Psilakis - Butter Pecan Ice Cream


Butter 

354 11th St San Francisco, CA (415) 863-5964

American Cafe 
A local dive-bar legend that serves up great music, good times and all the SpaghettiOs and deep-fried PB&Js you can stomach



Butter 

415 Lafayette St New York, NY (212) 253-2828

Michael Jenkins, Chef, Butter, New York, NY (winner)


Butter Lane 

123 E 7th St # 2 New York, NY (212) 677-2880

Bakery American 
Ted Allen - Banana Cupcakes


Cafe 222 

222 Island Ave San Diego, CA (619) 236-9902

New American 
Bobby Flay - Peanut Butter & Banana Stuffed French Toast

  • SILVER for Cafe 222

Capital City Bakery 

1901 Rio Grande St Austin, TX (512) 666-7437

A vegan peanut butter centric truck bakery that is spreading joy and peanut butter love in the form of whoopie pies, cupcakes to brownies al


Devilicious 

Moving Target San Diego, CA

Butter Poached Lobster Grilled Cheese sandwich, Chili Cheddar Stuffed Jalapenos and Spicy Tuna Nachos


Foolish Craig's Cafe 

1611 Pearl St Boulder, CO (303) 247-9383

Traditional American 
a crepe joint stacking them 21-high in a butter rum caramel cake

  • BRONZE for Foolish Craig's Cafe

Gilhooley's 

222 9TH St San Leon, TX (281) 339-3813

Seafood 
Some call Gilhooleys the most notorious oyster bar on the Gulf of Mexico, where the gritty ambience and the oysters make it the ultimate sea


Giovanni's Shrimp Truck 

56-505 Kamehameha Hwy Kahuku, HI

Whether it's scampi, hot n' spicy, or lemon and butter, surfers know the place to grab the best shrimp on Oahu is Giovanni's Shrimp Truck.

  • BRONZE for Giovanni's Shrimp Truck

Gooey Louie's 

6483 Chippewa St St. Louis, MO (314) 352-2253

Gooey butter cake feud.


Highland Bakery 

655 Highland Ave NE Atlanta, GA (404) 586-0772

Health Food 
For breakfast, check out Highland Bakery for their Bran flake crusted peanut butter French toast dripping with caramelized bananas!


Hubcap Grill 

1111 Prairie St Houston, TX (713) 223-5885

Hamburgers 
Big interesting burgers like burgers with Fritos, cheesesteak or peanut butter.

  • BRONZE for Hubcap Grill

J's Oyster 

5 Portland Pier Portland, ME (207) 772-4828

Seafood 
J‚??s is a dark pub-like atmosphere. There are plenty of oysters for the taking, but the real stars are the Maine clams, aka steamers. Tony


Krolls West 

1990 S Ridge Rd Green Bay, WI (920) 497-1111

Traditional American Pizza 
Krolls West is a gameday institution right across the street from Lambeau Field. Adam's pick? Their prime rib sandwich, 8 ounces of chargril


Le Bernardin 

155 W 51st St New York, NY (212) 554-1515

French Seafood 
Ted Allen - Black Bass

  • SILVER for Le Bernardin

Lola 

2058 E 4th St Tremont, OH (216) 621-5652

French Eclectic & International 
Michael Symon -

  • SILVER for Lola

MB Post 

1142 Manhattan Ave. Manhattan Beach, CA (310) 545-5405

Killer brussel sprouts, cooked in clarified brown butter, covered with cheese.


Park Ave. Coffee 

1919 Park Ave St. Louis, MO (314) 621-4020

Gooey butter cake feud.


Peanut Butter & Company 

240 Sullivan St New York, NY (212) 677-3995

Traditional American 

  • BRONZE for Peanut Butter & Company

Pnut Butter Bar 

Los Angeles, CA

Elvis sandwich made of bacon, peanut butter, bacon and honley.


Prime One Twelve 

112 Ocean Dr Miami, FL (305) 532-8112

Steakhouse Seafood 
Chris Santos - Chocolate Peanut Butter Smores


Prince Alberts Diner 

565 Richmond St. London, Canada (519) 432-2835

a burger staple that offers bacon and peanut butter on a quarter pound of dripping goodness


Prune 

54 E 1st St New York, NY (212) 677-6221

Traditional American Eclectic & International 
Chris Cosentino - Bacon & Marmalade Sandwich

  • BRONZE for Prune

Semi-Sweet Bakery 

105 E 6th St Los Angeles, CA (213) 228-9975

Bakery 
This bakery takes the simple out of homebaked goods, eleveating everything they touch with bursts of flavor, from 7up poundcake to blueberry


Short Leash Truck 

110 E. Roosevelt Phoenix, AZ

The Aiko, a naan wrapped sausage topped with Mango Chutney or the 7th Innings Stretch, a spicy beer weiner topped with peanut butter, Cracke


Snake River Brewery 

265 S Millward St Jackson, WY (307) 739-2337

New American 
The Roper (cayenne pepper & mustard powder spice rub brisket braised in apple cider & beer mixture, bacon, and horseradish stacked in betwee


SoWe 

918 S 22nd St Philadelphia, PA (215) 545-5790

New American 
Cinnamon beignets baked with brown butter, caramel and topped with crumbled bacon.


Solly's Grille 

4629 N Port Washington Rd Glendale, WI (414) 332-8808

Californian Traditional American 
George Motz visits Solly’s Grille to eat their famous Butter Burger, made with a heaping dollop of butter.


Swan Oyster Depot 

1517 Polk St San Francisco, CA (415) 673-1101

Traditional American Seafood 
One of Tony's favorite places to eat in America, Swan Oyster Depot is a casual spot that's first-come, first-serve, so breakfast is the best

  • SILVER for Swan Oyster Depot

The Reel Inn 

18661 Pacific Coast Hwy Malibu, CA (310) 456-8221

Seafood Chowder 
The Reel Inn has some of the freshest seafood along the PCH, and Adam casts his line for the sautéed Pacific Halibut -- halibut sautéed in


The Rumpus Room 

2689 Main St. Vancouver, Canada (604) 568-5663

vintage board games and waffle burgers, returning to childhood with kiddie classic snacks like ants on a log celery sticks with peanut butte


The Russian Banya 

2515 E Rosemeade Pkwy Ste 401 Carrollton, TX (214) 483-5050

Visit this Russian spa and restaurant, and sample their Russian pickles, cabbage and cured salmon roe with buttered bread and sour cream.


Tradewinds Cafe 

1697 Portland Rd Arundel, ME (207) 985-3701

Adam takes on the Manimal Challenge, which consists of 1 "Ocho" burger with cheese and onions, 2 kraut (or slaw) dogs, a side of fries, a Mo


Treats Truck Stop 

521 Court St New York, NY (718) 330-0200

this kid friendly neighborhood bakery is the mecca of all things peanut butter and sweet in Carroll Gardens, Brooklyn.


Two Smart Cookies 

181 Snelling Ave N Saint Paul, MN (612) 384-1069

These two Minnesota State Fair winning bakers are whipping up cookies that taste just like home and their peanut butter hideaway is the star


Volunteer Park Cafe 

1501 17th Ave E Seattle, WA (206) 328-3155

Bakery American 
known for its loyal regular customers, fresh baked goodies, and twists on traditional homespun desserts. Try the meyer lemon shaker pie or b


Voodoo Doughnuts 

22 SW Third Ave Portland, OR (503) 241-4704

Vegetarian Bakery 
Over 70 varieties of donuts.

  • GOLD for Voodoo Doughnuts

Wrappers Delight 

521 5th Ave S Nashville, TN (615) 330-0092

A Hip-Hop inspired truck has pimped out its menu with Ginger-Glazed Chicken, Grilled Tilapia in Coconut Cream and even a Peanut Butter and B


Yoder's Amish Restaurant 

3434 Bahia Vista St Sarasota, FL (941) 955-7771

fried chicken that was prepared in a special "pressure fryer", and later had a piece of their homemade peanut butter cream pie

  • GOLD for Yoder's Amish Restaurant

Restaurant Map

Show-Specific links for butter