Vine Street Cafe

TV Shows

Best Thing I Ever Ate

Episode: Hometown Favorites

Ina Garten - Pasta Bolognese

Nearby

Shows near Shelter Island

Rachael Ray - $40 a Day(6)

Best Thing I Ever Ate(5)

Drinking Made Easy(4)

Food Paradise(2)

Unique Eats(2)

Top Chef(1)

Restaurant Impossible(1)

Photos

Map & Directions

41 S Ferry Rd
Shelter Island , NY 11964
6317493210
Get Directions

Menu

Restaurant Details

Cuisines:

• Traditional American
• New American

Cost:

• $$$$

Features:

• Local Favorite
• Outdoor Dining
• Hidden Find
• Celeb Hangout

External Links:

• Learn more from CitySearch.
• Learn more from Google Places.

Comments & Tips

No comments yet!! Be the first!

You need to be logged in to leave a comment.
Login or Get your free account

CitySearch Tips

Look Good

The dress code here is casual-chic, so don your best linen tunic and keep an eye out for celebrity guests.

Know Before You Go

Don't be fooled by the quiet surroundings--Vine Street Cafe requires reservations, just like ever other spot in town.

What to Drink

Sip a local favorite, like a glass of Merlot from the nearby Lieb Cellars.

When to Go

The restaurant is closed on Tuesday and Wednesday during the off-season.

FourSquare Tips

• Travel + Leisure
  Foodies flock to Shelter Island for crisp calamari salad and miso salmon in this simple space with high, beamed ceilings.
• Tara B.
  Hamptons Restaurant Week is from March 21 - 28. Enjoy a 3-course prix fixe for $24.95. To see other participants visit the website at www.hamptonsrestaurantweek.com.
• Greg H.
  Go here. This is my favorite restaurant on Shelter Island. Chef proprietors led the kitchen at Sunset Beach for a few seasons before starting VSC.
• Alexandra K.
  Simply the best food on Shelter Island! Fav is the calamari salad and the chopped steak - great desserts too!
• Mickey B.
  A 5-minute ferry trip and you're there.
• Jennifer ? K.
  Bolognese!
• The Corcoran Group
  Chefs/Owners Lisa & Terry Harwood in 2002. Features daily "Plats du Jour," local seafood and produce, and desserts. Notable for the calamari salad and the famous Pineapple Tart Tatin.