Missing a place? Let us Know

Results 1-50 of 54 View All


Katz's Deli 

205 E Houston St New York, NY (212) 254-2246

Traditional American Eclectic & International 
Michael Psilakis - Knoblewurst

  • GOLD for Katz's Deli


Doughnut Plant 

379 Grand St New York, NY (212) 505-3700

Bakery Bagels 
Pat & Gina Neely - PB&J Doughnut

  • GOLD for Doughnut Plant


Peter Luger 

178 Broadway Brooklyn, NY (718) 387-7400

Michael Psilakis - Sizzling Bacon

  • GOLD for Peter Luger


Anchor Bar 

1047 Main St Buffalo, NY (716) 884-4083

Italian Californian 
Camille travels to Buffalo's Anchor Bar - the restaurant responsible for inventing Buffalo Chicken Wings in 1964. These are the original chi

  • GOLD for Anchor Bar



32 Spring St New York, NY (212) 941-7994

Italian Pizza 

  • GOLD for Lombardi's


Keens Steakhouse 

72 W 36th St New York, NY (212) 947-3636

Steakhouse Traditional American 
American Classics - Best Old School Steak.

  • GOLD for Keens Steakhouse


The Meatball Shop 

84 Stanton St New York, NY (212) 982-8895

Italian Traditional American 
In New York, he eats the goat Billy Balls at The Meatball Shop which has locals lining up until 4am for their succulent round morsels.

  • GOLD for The Meatball Shop


Serendipity 3 

225 E 60th St Manhattan, NY (212) 838-3531

Soups Traditional American 

  • GOLD for Serendipity 3


Carnegie Deli 

854 7th Ave New York, NY (212) 757-2245

The biggest sandwiches. Famous for their pastrami.

  • GOLD for Carnegie Deli



345 E 12th St New York, NY (212) 358-7912

Traditional American Southern 
Macoroni and Cheese Only Restaurant. 12 different mac and cheese - from all american, buffalo chicken, mediterean and they even have a samp

  • GOLD for S'Mac


Brick Lane Curry House 

306 E 6th St New York, NY (212) 979-2900

The challenge was to eat Spicy Phaal, claiming to be the hottest curry in the world. Adam finished the curry, got a complimentary beer, a c

  • SILVER for Brick Lane Curry House


Ray's Pizza 

204 9th Ave New York, NY (212) 243-1129


  • SILVER for Ray's Pizza



1310 Surf Ave Brooklyn, NY (718) 946-2705

Traditional American Hot Dogs 

  • SILVER for Nathan's


All American 

4286 Merrick Rd Massapequa, NY (516) 798-9574


  • SILVER for All American


Smith and Wollensky 

797 3rd Ave New York, NY (212) 753-1530

Anne Burrell - Coconut Layer Cake

  • SILVER for Smith and Wollensky


Chip Shop 

129 Atlantic Ave Brooklyn, NY (718) 855-7775

Known to fry up things like pizza and even bagels with lox.

  • SILVER for Chip Shop


Peanut Butter & Company 

240 Sullivan St New York, NY (212) 677-3995

Traditional American 

  • SILVER for Peanut Butter & Company



328 Lenox Ave Harlem, NY (212) 996-0660

Banana Pudding Sundae

  • BRONZE for Sylvia's



2287 1st Ave New York, NY (212) 534-9783

Italian Pizza 
Family owned Italian restaurant. A favorite of Frank Sinatra.

  • BRONZE for Patsy's


Old Homestead Steakhouse 

56 9th Ave New York, NY (212) 242-9040

Steakhouse Traditional American 

  • BRONZE for Old Homestead Steakhouse


Max & Mina's 

7126 Main St Queens, NY (718) 793-8629

,000 outrageous ice cream flavors like pizza, lox, beer and cookies, and corn

  • BRONZE for Max & Mina's



247 S 1st St Brooklyn, NY (718) 218-8047

New American 
Michael Psilakis - Meatloaf Sandwich

  • BRONZE for Rye



151 Union St Brooklyn, NY (718) 855-1545

Scott Conant - Vastedda

  • BRONZE for Ferdinando's


Murray's Bagels 

500 Avenue Of The Americas New York, NY (212) 462-2830

Sandwiches Bakery 

  • BRONZE for Murray's Bagels


Stage Deli & Restaurant Incorporated 

834 7TH Ave New York, NY (212) 245-7850

  • BRONZE for Stage Deli & Restaurant Incorporated


Paulie Gee's  

60 Greenpoint Ave Brooklyn, NY (347) 987-3747

Italian Pizza 
Ricotta be kidding me pizza.



485 Lorimer St New York, NY (718) 388-8820

Italian Pizza 
Forcella has taken the New York pizza scene by storm with a menu that includes fried pizza, fried calzones, fried desserts and a small selec


The Palm 

837 2nd Ave New York, NY (212) 687-2953

Steakhouse Traditional American 


Pig Heaven 

1540 2nd Ave New York, NY (212) 744-4887



Buffalo Wing Festival 

Buffalo, NY

Traditional American 
Largest wing festival.


Newest Lunch 

715 Albany St Schenectady, NY (518) 377-6580

East coast version of the Detroit coney island dog.



18 W 18th St New York, NY (917) 675-3385

Bacon Desserts


Pop Burger 

14 E 58th St New York, NY (212) 991-6644




62 Thomas St New York, NY (212) 964-7777



Empire Diner 

210 10th Ave New York, NY (212) 243-2736

Traditional American 



1126 ERIE BLVD Schenectady, NY (518) 370-0555

Steak Sandwiches 
Pat's and Geno's in Philly aren't the only places to get a great cheesesteak -- believe it or not, one of the best around can be found in Sc



54 Prince St New York, NY (212) 226-0211

New American 
Macbar puts a gourmet twist on this childhood comfort food. With 12 different kinds of mac and cheese infused with gourmet culinary creation


Petite Abeille 

466 Hudson St New York, NY (212) 741-6479

French Belgian 


Tweeds Restaurant and Buffalo Bar 

17 E Main St Riverhead, NY (631) 208-3151

Traditional American 
Just a short drive from the Big Apple is Tweeds, where they serve buffalo, an animal that weighs about 2,000 lbs. This makes for some big sl



1524 Neptune Ave Brooklyn, NY (718) 372-8606

Thin crust NY style pizza.


Whistle Pig CLOSED 

7001 Packard Rd Niagara Falls, NY (716) 299-0333

Hot dog wrapped in bacon and deep fried.



260 Bleecker St New York, NY (212) 243-1974

Italian sandwiches


Lasagna Ristorante 

196 8th Ave New York, NY (212) 242-4551

17 different types of lasagna.


Jive Turkey 

441 Myrtle Ave Brooklyn, NY (718) 797-1688

Traditional American 


Tuck Shop 

68 East 1st St New York, NY (212) 979-5200

Bakery American 
Australian meat pie.



18 Woodbine Ave Northport, NY (631) 757-4500

Maroni’s Cuisine has evolved into an extremely popular, yet very eclectic restaurant that offers a marathon tasting menu of 14 co


Sparks Steak House 

210 E 46th St New York, NY (212) 687-4855

Steakhouse Seafood 
Old school steak house. Only offer 2 cuts, filet and prime sirloin.


Nino's Bellisima 

1354 1st Ave New York, NY (212) 988-0002



Rachel's Taqueria 

408 5th Ave Brooklyn, NY (718) 788-1137

Mole infused burrito.


Bleeker Street Pizza 

193 Bleecker St New York, NY (212) 533-6600

Nonna Maria Pizza

Restaurant Map

Local Deals