Summary

Nick and Toni's in East Hampton, NY is an American-Italian restaurant with an extensive wine list and an outdoor patio. It has been featured on the popular TV show, Best Thing I Ever Ate, and is known for its delicious food and relaxed atmosphere.

Seen On

BEST

Best Thing I Ever Ate

Genuine Legends 01-12-2020

Josh Capon Tartufo

More restaurants on Best Thing I Ever Ate Near East Hampton , NY

Nearby Restaurants

Carissa's the Bakery

Carissa's the Bakery

East Hampton,NY
Best Thing I Ever Ate
8.1
TVFScore

Alex Guarnaschelli Salty Soured Pickled Rye Bread

Air Date: 01-12-2020
Mary's Marvelous

Mary's Marvelous

East Hampton,NY $$$
Closed
Rachael Ray - $40 a Day
4.7
TVFScore

Mary's Marvelous in East Hampton, NY is a local favorite that has been featured on Rachael Ray - $40 a Day. It's a family-r ...

Fast Food Bakery Healthy

1770 House Restaurant & Inn

1770 House Restaurant & Inn

East Hampton,NY $$$$
Best Thing I Ever Ate
28.2
TVFScore

Ina Garten - Meatloaf

New American

Townline BBQ

Townline BBQ

Sagaponack,NY $$
Best Thing I Ever Ate
8.2
TVFScore

Katie Lee Buffalo Fries

Air Date: 01-12-2020
Loaves & Fishes Food Store

Loaves & Fishes Food Store

Sagaponack,NY $$$$
Best Thing I Ever Ate
27.1
TVFScore

Ina Garten - Shrimp and Swordfish Curry

Seafood American Bistro

Sen Japanese Restaurant

Sen Japanese Restaurant

Sag Harbor,NY $$$
Rachael Ray - $40 a Day
24.6
TVFScore

Sen Japanese Restaurant in Sag Harbor, NY has been featured on TV shows like Rachael Ray - $40 a Day. This popular sushi sp ...

Japanese Sushi

Pierre's

Pierre's

Bridgehampton,NY $$$
Best Thing I Ever Ate
18.6
TVFScore

Rocco DiSpirito - Buche De Noel

French Seafood

Air Date: 12-05-2011
The Lobster Roll Amagansett

The Lobster Roll Amagansett

Amagansett,NY
Closed
Seen on TV/Movies
12.1
TVFScore

Where the Affair begins (and great lobster rolls).

Cyril's Fish House

Cyril's Fish House

Montauk,NY $$
Closed
Drinking Made Easy
19.8
TVFScore

Famous for their BBC cocktail.

Seafood

Air Date: 12-26-2012
Vine Street Café

Vine Street Café

Shelter Island,NY $$$
Best Thing I Ever Ate
26.5
TVFScore

Ina Garten - Pasta Bolognese

Traditional American New American

Ruschmeyer's

Ruschmeyer's

Montauk,NY $$$
Unique Eats
16.5
TVFScore

Utilizes all the local seafood, much more than just a restaurant. Known for their smoked blue fish pate.

Seafood American Catering

Air Date: 01-15-2012
Navy Beach

Navy Beach

Montauk,NY $$$
Drinking Made Easy
8.8
TVFScore

What was once navy housing for the local navy base has turned into a great seaside bar with freshly made and original drinks.

Seafood New American

Air Date: 12-26-2012
John's Pancake House

John's Pancake House

Montauk,NY $$
Bite This with Nadia G
14.5
TVFScore

Fried Ice Cream

Air Date: 07-28-2014
Surf Lodge

Surf Lodge

Montauk,NY
Closed
Food Paradise +1
35.2
TVFScore

Sea Urching Linguini

Seafood American

Air Date: 11-05-2017
East by Northeast

East by Northeast

Montauk,NY
Bite This with Nadia G
1.1
TVFScore

Lobster Tempura Roll

Air Date: 07-28-2014
The Montauk Beach House

The Montauk Beach House

Montauk,NY
Drinking Made Easy
14.5
TVFScore

This is the areas premier weekend destination for top DJ™s, live music, and fancy cars

Air Date: 12-26-2012
Montauk Brewing Company

Montauk Brewing Company

Montauk,NY
Drinking Made Easy
24.6
TVFScore

Montauks first and only brewery is bent on capturing the local flavor in their beer.

Air Date: 12-26-2012
Clam and Chowder House at Salivar's Dock

Clam and Chowder House at Salivar's Dock

Montauk,NY $$
Closed
Food Paradise
10.1
TVFScore

Tuna steak with sticky rice and sushi pizza

Air Date: 10-15-2017
The Dock Bar & Grill

The Dock Bar & Grill

Montauk,NY
Closed
Bite This with Nadia G
23.5
TVFScore

Montauk Clam chowder

Air Date: 07-28-2014

Top Restaurants

Katz's Delicatessen

Katz's Delicatessen

New York,NY $$
Best Thing I Ever Ate +7
100.0
TVFScore

Michael Psilakis - Knoblewurst

Traditional American Eclectic & International Hot Dogs

Air Date: 11-29-2010
Cafe Du Monde French Market

Cafe Du Monde French Market

New Orleans,LA $
Delicious Destinations +2
100.0
TVFScore

At Café du Monde, you’ll find near-perfect New Orleans doughnuts topped with powdered sugar, called beignets. But don’t ...

Air Date: 03-02-2015
Lou Malnati's Pizzeria

Lou Malnati's Pizzeria

Chicago,IL $$
You Gotta Eat Here +6
100.0
TVFScore

the oldest family name in deep-dish pizza. Layer after layer of cheese, meat, veggies and sauce, bake on a delicate, buttery ...

Italian Pizza

Air Date: 07-04-2014
Chaps Pit Beef

Chaps Pit Beef

Baltimore,MD $$
Best Thing I Ever Ate +4
99.9
TVFScore

Guy Fieri - Chaps Submarine

Air Date: 06-01-2008
Gino's East

Gino's East

Chicago,IL $$
United States of Bacon +3
99.9
TVFScore

He feasts his eyes on a mammoth deep-dish pizza overflowing with meat and, of course, tons of bacon.

Italian Pizza

Air Date: 12-30-2012
Tony Luke's

Tony Luke's

Philadelphia,PA $$
Best Thing I Ever Ate +6
99.9
TVFScore

Marc Summers - Cheesesteak

Italian Cheesesteak Fast Food

Primanti Bros.

Primanti Bros.

Pittsburgh,PA $
Bizarre Foods America +5
99.9
TVFScore

Located in the Strip District, Primanti Brothers is a legendary fast-food joint known for its sandwiches, always topped with ...

Traditional American

Air Date: 11-11-2013
Al's Beef

Al's Beef

Chicago,IL $
Food Wars +4
99.9
TVFScore

Camille visits Al's Italian beef -- a Chicago staple for 70 years -- to learn about the restaurant, its history and to experi...

Italian Steakhouse Fast Food

Air Date: 03-09-2010
Pat's King of Steaks

Pat's King of Steaks

Philadelphia,PA $$
Food Feuds +2
99.9
TVFScore

Cheesesteak Feud - Winner!

Steakhouse Soups Cheesesteak

Air Date: 10-10-2010
Pappy's Smokehouse

Pappy's Smokehouse

St. Louis,MO $$
Food Feuds +2
99.8
TVFScore

Ribs Food Feud.

Air Date: 11-18-2010
The Varsity

The Varsity

Atlanta,GA
Food Paradise
99.8
TVFScore

The Varsity in Atlanta, GA is an iconic fast-food restaurant that has been featured on popular TV shows like Food Paradise. ...

Traditional American Hamburgers Hot Dogs

Mother's Restaurant

Mother's Restaurant

New Orleans,LA $$
Best Thing I Ever Ate +2
99.8
TVFScore

Sunny Anderson - Bread Pudding

Traditional American Cajun & Creole

Acme Oyster House

Acme Oyster House

New Orleans,LA $$
Man vs Food +1
99.8
TVFScore

This episode's challenge was to finish 15 dozen oysters at Acme Oyster House and join the "15 Dozen Club". Adam succeeded in ...

Seafood Cajun & Creole

Air Date: 01-28-2009
Geno's Steaks

Geno's Steaks

Philadelphia,PA $$
Food Feuds +1
99.8
TVFScore

Cheesesteak feud - loser.

Steakhouse Soups Traditional American

Air Date: 10-10-2010
Kuma's Corner

Kuma's Corner

Chicago,IL $$
Best Thing I Ever Ate +5
99.8
TVFScore

Adam Gertler - Plague Bringer Burger

Traditional American Hamburgers

Air Date: 11-29-2010
Joe's Kansas City Bar-B-Que

Joe's Kansas City Bar-B-Que

Kansas City,KS $$
Man vs Food +4
99.8
TVFScore

Adam Richman heads to Oklahoma Joe's for succulent pulled pork and saucy spare ribs. This award-winning barbecue does the cit...

Sandwiches Cafe Catering

Air Date: 08-11-2010
Melt Bar and Grilled

Melt Bar and Grilled

Lakewood,OH $$
Best Thing I Ever Ate +3
99.7
TVFScore

Anne Thornton - The Godfather

Traditional American Vegetarian Sandwiches

Air Date: 09-26-2011
Voodoo Doughnut

Voodoo Doughnut

Portland,OR $
Best Bars in America +4
99.7
TVFScore

Great place to end a bar crawl

Vegetarian Bakery Ice Cream

Air Date: 06-25-2014
Philippe The Original

Philippe The Original

Los Angeles,CA $
Best Thing I Ever Ate +3
99.7
TVFScore

Wolfgang Puck - French Dipped Sandwiches

Soups French Traditional American

Air Date: 09-27-2010
Hash House A Go Go

Hash House A Go Go

Las Vegas,NV $$
Man vs Food +1
99.7
TVFScore

Fried Chicken Eggs Benedict

Traditional American New American

Air Date: 08-12-2009