90.6
TVFScore

The Old Fashioned

23 North Pinckney Street, Madison, WI

Summary

The Old Fashioned in Madison, WI is an iconic Wisconsin tavern that has been featured on TV shows such as Best Thing I Ever Ate, Crave, and others. The tavern offers a unique atmosphere, classic Wisconsin food, and a wide selection of local beers and spirits.

Seen On

BEST

Best Thing I Ever Ate

All American 09-12-2011

Troy Johnson - Fried Cheese Curds

More restaurants on Best Thing I Ever Ate Near Madison , WI
CRAVE

Crave

Cheese: Milk Does Hard Time 10-21-2011

Beer battered fried cheese curds

More restaurants on Crave Near Madison , WI

Cuisines & Features

  • Steak
  • Vegetarian
  • Sandwiches
  • American
  • Traditional

Nearby Restaurants

L'Etoile

L'Etoile

Madison,WI $$$$
Bizarre Foods America
41.3
TVFScore

L'Etoile in Madison, WI is a renowned French restaurant that has been featured on Bizarre Foods America for its rich and fl ...

French European American

Air Date: 03-11-2013
Graze

Graze

Madison,WI $$
Bizarre Foods America
50.2
TVFScore

Graze in Madison, WI is a modern American restaurant offering a unique dining experience that has been featured on TV shows ...

American Cafe Gastropub

Air Date: 03-11-2013
Ian's Pizza on State

Ian's Pizza on State

Madison,WI $
Food Paradise
43.2
TVFScore

Crazy topped pizzas.

Pizza

Air Date: 08-19-2015
Chocolate Shoppe Ice Cream Co.

Chocolate Shoppe Ice Cream Co.

Madison,WI $
Crave
60.9
TVFScore

Chocolate Shoppe Ice Cream Co. in Madison, WI has been delighting taste buds since 1962 and has grown to be a household nam ...

Air Date: 09-12-2011
University of Wisconsin-Madison

University of Wisconsin-Madison

Madison,WI
Food Paradise
25.5
TVFScore

University of Wisconsin, Madison, Wisconsin

Gail Ambrosius Chocolatier

Gail Ambrosius Chocolatier

Madison,WI
America's Best
51.1
TVFScore

Best little box of chocolates.

Air Date: 09-23-2010
Ella's Deli and Ice Cream Parlor

Ella's Deli and Ice Cream Parlor

Madison,WI $$
Closed
Craziest Restaurants in America
26.1
TVFScore

Number 2 of the weirdest restaurants. Over 100 miniature animitronics and known for over the top ice cream desserts like the...

Air Date: 06-24-2015
Village Bar

Village Bar

Madison,WI $
Burger Land
54.4
TVFScore

George Motz visits the Village Bar for the first time and finds that their practice of steam-melting cheese make the restaura...

Air Date: 09-02-2012
Wedl's Hamburger Stand *Closes Nov. 17th 2019 for the season* reopens mid March 2020

Wedl's Hamburger Stand *Closes Nov. 17th 2019 for the season* reopens mid March 2020

Jefferson,WI $
Burger Land
52.7
TVFScore

George visits WEDL’s hamburger stand to try their burgers, which are fried with onions in a pan of lard. He talks with the ...

Hamburgers

Air Date: 09-02-2012
Baumgartner's Cheese Store & Tavern

Baumgartner's Cheese Store & Tavern

Monroe,WI $
Food Paradise
52.9
TVFScore

Baumgartners opened in 1931, making it the oldest cheese store in Wisconsin. It specializes in the finest array of Wisconsin ...

Air Date: 03-06-2013
MACS (Macaroni and Cheese Shop) Wisconsin Dells

MACS (Macaroni and Cheese Shop) Wisconsin Dells

Wisconsin Dells,WI $$
Food Paradise
60.3
TVFScore

Chili Mac and Hangover Mac.

Air Date: 08-26-2015

Top Restaurants

Katz's Delicatessen

Katz's Delicatessen

New York,NY $$
Best Thing I Ever Ate +7
100.0
TVFScore

Michael Psilakis - Knoblewurst

Traditional American Eclectic & International Hot Dogs

Air Date: 11-29-2010
Cafe Du Monde French Market

Cafe Du Monde French Market

New Orleans,LA $
Delicious Destinations +2
100.0
TVFScore

At Café du Monde, you’ll find near-perfect New Orleans doughnuts topped with powdered sugar, called beignets. But don’t ...

Air Date: 03-02-2015
Lou Malnati's Pizzeria

Lou Malnati's Pizzeria

Chicago,IL $$
You Gotta Eat Here +6
100.0
TVFScore

the oldest family name in deep-dish pizza. Layer after layer of cheese, meat, veggies and sauce, bake on a delicate, buttery ...

Italian Pizza

Air Date: 07-04-2014
Chaps Pit Beef

Chaps Pit Beef

Baltimore,MD $$
Best Thing I Ever Ate +4
99.9
TVFScore

Guy Fieri - Chaps Submarine

Air Date: 06-01-2008
Gino's East

Gino's East

Chicago,IL $$
United States of Bacon +3
99.9
TVFScore

He feasts his eyes on a mammoth deep-dish pizza overflowing with meat and, of course, tons of bacon.

Italian Pizza

Air Date: 12-30-2012
Tony Luke's

Tony Luke's

Philadelphia,PA $$
Best Thing I Ever Ate +6
99.9
TVFScore

Marc Summers - Cheesesteak

Italian Cheesesteak Fast Food

Primanti Bros.

Primanti Bros.

Pittsburgh,PA $
Bizarre Foods America +5
99.9
TVFScore

Located in the Strip District, Primanti Brothers is a legendary fast-food joint known for its sandwiches, always topped with ...

Traditional American

Air Date: 11-11-2013
Al's Beef

Al's Beef

Chicago,IL $
Food Wars +4
99.9
TVFScore

Camille visits Al's Italian beef -- a Chicago staple for 70 years -- to learn about the restaurant, its history and to experi...

Italian Steakhouse Fast Food

Air Date: 03-09-2010
Pat's King of Steaks

Pat's King of Steaks

Philadelphia,PA $$
Food Feuds +2
99.9
TVFScore

Cheesesteak Feud - Winner!

Steakhouse Soups Cheesesteak

Air Date: 10-10-2010
Pappy's Smokehouse

Pappy's Smokehouse

St. Louis,MO $$
Food Feuds +2
99.8
TVFScore

Ribs Food Feud.

Air Date: 11-18-2010
The Varsity

The Varsity

Atlanta,GA
Food Paradise
99.8
TVFScore

The Varsity in Atlanta, GA is an iconic fast-food restaurant that has been featured on popular TV shows like Food Paradise. ...

Traditional American Hamburgers Hot Dogs

Mother's Restaurant

Mother's Restaurant

New Orleans,LA $$
Best Thing I Ever Ate +2
99.8
TVFScore

Sunny Anderson - Bread Pudding

Traditional American Cajun & Creole

Acme Oyster House

Acme Oyster House

New Orleans,LA $$
Man vs Food +1
99.8
TVFScore

This episode's challenge was to finish 15 dozen oysters at Acme Oyster House and join the "15 Dozen Club". Adam succeeded in ...

Seafood Cajun & Creole

Air Date: 01-28-2009
Geno's Steaks

Geno's Steaks

Philadelphia,PA $$
Food Feuds +1
99.8
TVFScore

Cheesesteak feud - loser.

Steakhouse Soups Traditional American

Air Date: 10-10-2010
Kuma's Corner

Kuma's Corner

Chicago,IL $$
Best Thing I Ever Ate +5
99.8
TVFScore

Adam Gertler - Plague Bringer Burger

Traditional American Hamburgers

Air Date: 11-29-2010
Joe's Kansas City Bar-B-Que

Joe's Kansas City Bar-B-Que

Kansas City,KS $$
Man vs Food +4
99.8
TVFScore

Adam Richman heads to Oklahoma Joe's for succulent pulled pork and saucy spare ribs. This award-winning barbecue does the cit...

Sandwiches Cafe Catering

Air Date: 08-11-2010
Melt Bar and Grilled

Melt Bar and Grilled

Lakewood,OH $$
Best Thing I Ever Ate +3
99.7
TVFScore

Anne Thornton - The Godfather

Traditional American Vegetarian Sandwiches

Air Date: 09-26-2011
Voodoo Doughnut

Voodoo Doughnut

Portland,OR $
Best Bars in America +4
99.7
TVFScore

Great place to end a bar crawl

Vegetarian Bakery Ice Cream

Air Date: 06-25-2014
Philippe The Original

Philippe The Original

Los Angeles,CA $
Best Thing I Ever Ate +3
99.7
TVFScore

Wolfgang Puck - French Dipped Sandwiches

Soups French Traditional American

Air Date: 09-27-2010
Hash House A Go Go

Hash House A Go Go

Las Vegas,NV $$
Man vs Food +1
99.7
TVFScore

Fried Chicken Eggs Benedict

Traditional American New American

Air Date: 08-12-2009